Question 3
[Marks 60]
3.1 When one deliberately keeps oneself ignorant to escape responsibility, that ignorance
does not excuse the wrongful injury. When is a person morally responsible for an injury
or a wrong?
(3)
3.2 Monopoly markets are said to be unethical. What are the immoralities or ethical
weaknesses of such markets?
(6)
3.3 You are a senior executive at a pharmaceutical company responsible for approving new
drug trials. One of the trials under consideration involves testing a drug developed by a
close relative who works for a different pharmaceutical company.
(a) The mere fact that one of the trials under consideration involves testing a drug
developed by a close relative place you as a senior executive in a dilemma. Name and
explain the type of dilemma that you find yourself in.
(8)
(b) How would you handle this dilemma to ensure fairness in the recruitment process?
(2)
3.4 The fact that political tactics are usually covert means that they can easily become
deceptive or manipulative and therefore unethical. Identify five examples of political
tactics used in organizations.
(10)
3.5 Arguments against job discrimination are generally grouped in three moral principles.
Outline the arguments against discrimination.
(6)
3.6 Some people are very allergic to peanuts or things derived from peanuts. A food company
uses peanut oil in its products. On the ingredients list, the company only lists "vegetable
oil" without specifying "peanut oil."
(a)
According to the contractual view, explain the four main moral duties of a
business to its customers.
(8)
(b)
In your opinion, did the company adhere to all the moral duties it has toward
its customers? Motivate your answer.
(3)
3.7 A company advertises its new skincare product as "clinically proven to erase wrinkles in
just one week." The advertisement features before-and-after photos of individuals with
visibly smoother and younger-looking skin after using the product. However, upon closer
inspection, the company's claims are based on a small, unrepresentative sample size of
individuals and do not accurately reflect the typical results of using the product.
6