 |
CAC610S - COMPARATIVE AFRICAN CITIES - 2ND OPP - JULY 2022 |
|
|
1 Page 1 |
▲back to top |
nAm I BIA un IVERSITY
OF SCIEnCE Ano TECHnOLOGY
FACULTY OF ENGINEERING AND SPATIAL SCIENCES
DEPARTMENT OF ARCHITECTURE AND SPATIAL SCENCES
QUALIFICATION: BACHELOR OF TOWN AND REGIONAL PLANNING
QUALIFICATION CODE: 07BTAR
LEVEL: 6
COURSE CODE: CAC610S
DATE: JULY 2022
DURATION: 3 HOURS
COURSE NAME: COMPARATIVE AFRICAN CITIES
PAPER: Theory
MARKS: 100
SECOND OPPORTUNITY/SUPPLEMENTARY EXAMINATION QUESTION PAPER
LECTURERS: Jane Gold (igold@nust.na)
MODERATOR: Nadine Korrubel (nkorrubel@nust.na)
INSTRUCTIONS
1. Answer all the questions.
2. You may answer the questions in any order.
THIS QUESTION PAPER CONSISTS OF 4 PAGES (Including this front page)
|
|
2 Page 2 |
▲back to top |
Comparative African Cities
Question 1
CAC610S
Study the picture below of the city of Cape Town in South Africa. With reference to the urban
structure and form, demonstrate how the city can be described as a city of two parts.
[10]
Question 2
Discuss how the apartheid city influenced the city structure in Namibia. You may use diagram/s to
make the point.
[10]
Question 3
The traditional Ovambo homestead is a typical example that follows traditional structure of
planning in Africa. Draw, label and explain this concept.
[10]
Question 4
Identify and justify the most important recommendations made in the newspaper report below that
respond to the most pressing needs of informal settlements in Namibia.
Supplementary Memorandum
Page 2 of4
July 2022
|
|
3 Page 3 |
▲back to top |
Comparative African Cities
CAC610S
3
m
This i~ infm,nod b,
::~- ·d~lC!)1•dud-
·.:d!1l:m.:tjc··lot 1..::.
.:c.:h .5 r.ib,_ ·1~k
t,:utibid,OtJir:.'2i.·01,-
:;i), ~C:1~rf).,1Mu-Hfo,
011rn 10 ~.1tdO::;-
h:./:ctH.
-~i:,:.1ly·t1;:=ht pcrc:.:nl
t1fhi:.1w1i:,i11f:.1rm:1J
5d!lt:r:1c:1t:: dn i."'lCI
hrwr• ~(,Ht.1,,1 111•D!1.:v1.+
o;im:-nt Wc,rl:ilrnp lD',\\1!
M)~
Tl:!:; 1s.l1ikwm,d tw,
l)lo:1y ront.l,.;:-:ed lll'rrn.j,;,r
:c.•.•:,1:{.,1.-:haJ1:,·i11,Jlw1.•k.
~1.rit: ib, t1~j1w:1r1:n30,
!~;1fi1~,a f,h.1lil~,.(l-r1Ju,-o
n,d l).sl:.~l:;itl,u·hc;l! th(:
l:1~~m,I >-.: lif.111~l.Jf in·
f,:,rnil.J :-:~ttl,:.m nt::. .;.ri!
loc.:t,1,d.
T:1~s ,:~un: w.is mada::
I. ,1r,w11 1;:, !ir1:1phnni t·
~:n,- f.':tn..:b. who i~ the c[m•
.nll:.11_£e;,;1.,;,111 f1;•
h:n ii;11 fc r D'N, d:irins; io·.-;1.::.v-1:,.t:h th,: .l tltor:.. with ,·0Jt1:ll!"1!'r.;<o~cn~i• f'rosr.~r-ts f•l.in for~- c 'l'I:.~ .;oi.•~mn.:,--:nt plru.u (Lt,;r~n nn1I \\\\"Uc-.:-, S:.u.
h-.!r cr.-r.tHh111i,:,r1t;I :i 1"fe111m> <1ht,:17it:,tii,:,n-, fo1.·l.'<tllll;)UI -, j l,.1l111jlil 11""'"~rt'"t1:1Y\\';lH. ~,..11H:1- I<• 1~1t1·,d1 (\\:-1tm1,11d- i1:11k,ri :,w.1 Kn!il•:1•!
sti"i!::-llcklcr,:~~t!f::-,,ent pric,.rit}',~we ;,re.~- .er:,:- t:,lh:l!; n11dcl·.Jn~t!:-61:.·;- tiun ;s :.lso .i priori!/.
ty-li!d T•:it.il S.111it:i~rn'.il (','li'\\!:-1!) .1•~·,.rcnc.1srs,in
.z.lu;.J.11,111),:1n.i:ti!! 11f11- ~J1~;-.t-: ill :,II !t-Ydj," .~It~ ic~ur."~lie 1ml1.!.J
fo:ip.i:wv d<!:i1i;u·Jc:iyn :ippcnled.
T\\'H!:.l;u:u.,::u:.;;he c:111·
1'inn\\i1Ji:i 111'1d:11 ~:.rli:1- D'1Y·.-,t1.L...i.;-~:h..:U1uml~-ti;1:11!d, t<;,;p1n1!~ th1,;-.rn
mcnt ori We::!l:u:.:tday: nl t io-t.•.n1Jlt~t,l .!111tho1·- u..'111) 11,'11iii l11!0i.'H1:ll $.?:-
,r.. r.. iri Jin~ with Parli:.- itic-.1to .:,1~'k~ i11fol'm.il t.h!mentr. lo d~adl:r di$-
mn1t':. :,t1J1~r:111fmfP,•H;h ,ol I ltmll!tll (IJ;~11-c:~rf~- :-..,.::;~t,.·Hld1a~ :LIHI ,;
·.:r.rn'.!; ~;rnit;H.:m lo be .:ut!n.. !1'l!l!.
Th•! p,:,~r:.mtnl! i:,:betni;
r,l:H ·d ar llrn ;_Y(ll11•;1:,. ii
:.;.:.:·cn:.I~ornr.,)rtlr.•n. - CoRl:bo,,ntlon
rulJl!'-·•J:"Ill i:nc1~h1d. iC1,r•
Jlt h),', ~IS,
"On ::!.·,-c::.~e.:,r.1112',"';•.~1.llt: h:r;l! :-.ir •b:wri:;h}p DW ir.;; rcci~t,!:-,xl N:1•
of ;.:~•id{•flld Iii l11(,1n11al v.·ith!'111in.•i1:i!tr:<-~uL;1,!• 11111,i:Jm-,:~;\\(J).'irl1.t.r,.'-'1.,.,
:;:u:kmt!nl'i hil\\'! n tu:kt t 1c:ul~c.ri!11mllu-~l1h~11,:I ,;1n:;ui;l.l.l11abl~ U!'11&111.lc•
-,t 1:.-:,n!~AIL"l1J:~::•-tt:'~:i·re :nP:-t: ·W!!\\'.'11r:with the ·n.!lvpm!-nt.i:1forn-.::~.lct-
1.1;;i,~~1J.~ I1u:1I•. 1,.:;.3i1;111 ·,:,~.ii1111111ir:ip~Elits.0•.1r-llcmtll':~ ;,nd Lh>!di~.d-
phls:11f:l1!1!J 1H' ti:,· 11",· Y· 1..llit1~, :111~ii-1Ow 1111rn;..:, \\'111ll:l.!,;lt1l 1:1:•tllOlll(l!llll";.
b!cl}'r.hc.s:iid:.
•FAIJlf 1,fftr•,:;:, '-"'i~.:.rn rh..:.tt'l..":oidicn tncm. :t
fund.1 ::~jd t:11.:wy a:it Jw;1rdcd :;i,;i:_el._N~t,~\\:>r!: the. :icc,:-nd [l.i.r.imbL•t.:
c~J~l• l:._\\·;:.ii..t•hmn•,•.11)h
tlu.: 1::,111:1111r.it-1•,:1H\\.Ofnh~-
tk,11 <1fl;1trin•!; :ii l~-:OU!":!-
l 111i1JI1·>.·di1~Urli:1111111I
i::•~riurh,1i: ,11\\!,g_
011ti C:t'l'f!{:,'C,
ouly n% ofns-
idc-nts iu ilifor··
mnJ se'itlcmcnt-,,
fNIFt! 11to/let lit
lm,,•lt'.
S.t~p11tinhrJ:1!':r:Cli,
Can::.ultl11s-;1cvbc1:
0l.'\\·~1orrnierrvl ,•~t•
::her, (Dt.'l)
T.1c 1mt-Hinus ril.:1:i,i:;,
1•1H·i-:•~!1•~ ;•u~,1.1 11!11"!_rn. -
•,~c:~lmer.l5iu:,:. !lie 1J.:-
•,••:h,·1u-11,1.r111,-1u1a~. 1•1
nn.:.•~c...-er Inf ra:::tn10.:·
l•.1rt~.!(1_: -: 1 •,;, ,., :1qi 11;1~1l
lhL"rcm;11nir.,1: ..:.-::tiud.!'I:
l(1ilt-l'jllSht•.(I :,·1·:.,
•tlnQJ
[10]
Question 5
"The urban poor who eke out a livelihood in Africa's slums arguably pay the highest transaction cost
to be in the city: a clear manifestation of the systematic failure of states and the market."
Discussthe primary drivers of urban policy failure that are relevant to Namibia.
[10]
Question 6
Throughout Africa there are repetitive urban forms dating back to precolonial times. Identify and
discuss the most significant characteristics.
[10]
Supplementary Memorandum
Page 3 of4
July 2022
|
|
4 Page 4 |
▲back to top |
Comparative African Cities
CAC610S
Question 7
Discuss and evaluate the impact of colonialism exploitation on the continent, based on the map
below indicating the major ports and railway network in Africa.
---'
-Railway
A Major Port
[10]
Question 8
African cities are growing the fastest globally.
Analyse trends summarised by Citiscope and Gabriela Rico (Five trends in Africa's rapid
urbanisation, 2016) that are relevant to the Namibian situation.
[15]
Question 9
There are seven "building blocks of a new urban practice" to address the drivers of dysfunctionality.
Discuss these in the context for rebuilding the Namibian urban agenda. (One mark per building
block with one mark for discussion. An extra mark for explaining well)
[15]
TOTAL MARKS
Supplementary Memorandum
Page 4 of4
100
July 2022
|
|
5 Page 5 |
▲back to top |
Comparative African Cities
CAC610S
3
This is infonnod t,y
.i ~iucly c:.:-1111-0cl-
Qdll2 mDJot··tot1:n.:;
=c,:hL.5 ~'.11rrt3u}ck.
i.:;,ribil>O, tiil','el'Otl•
:;.)~[::rii1n.1 1'u~iBo,.
pm·.ioa'iaO:-:-
1.\\-•:~;ntl.
' .,:,--:::1,,!.~_7, .i.;:r
!' ;, ..
•
1..-".:.. 1. ••
.. ....~'
:,, . '
·~tt~ ~~-~~)(}~>.-:/J:'·.i.i.1 ) ," • ' • ·•., .•••
=-· . ----- -'!j_-f -
Ou nccrYJp,1•,
i~~;~l~I~:
~,:l!lcme:>l~ dn :-ilH
1·1~1•,t'O1·ill.•fi, 1 '·' fh,:•)1.-l-
c;im~Tit Wurl:ihnr.-lO'.VJ
,s.,_,~
Th.I:; 1:;.r.r,ir1lh•.I t,vJ
j·.
--.:~~~~
on!JJJ2~\\~ ofn:s-
·-·
illcnts ill infv;·•
ma! srltlt-rmmts
bmit: o to/Id ,ir
/Jiime.
!)lt.:h· rnmh:::ed ln li'..::;1,jr
:,.•.•:u:.,, ·h 11,'\\Vi11~1111)1Jk
l\\:u:bib. O~jw:u'!r. e:,1.
1{~1Ji1:1:1 l-J~1lii,u,O-IIJ\\1{1
,,nl D~h:J::,ti, ~·11c~(he
S,1~piw11it! fl'ltr:..::lt,
Co11::;ultl11iJ~C1,l.:.cn
DtH't'loprn-:<~ !/,'c};ri1•
!;hc;,(.DW)
111.~1•::.; h;·1i-.:1m, v! in-
fo:ir:-n:i~i ::ttlc-m;:nu ..:t.rl'.!
T'."ltl:.:Jllb1tiuu.:r:l:1:1iii~•)
1!)1:111,..1. .
,m••i~;•f!I•~1-,11,;1.i,l'ti~u~~u-
'T:i:.~f.;ure ,..,.::irsn11dc:
'/1!:.lm1:nl~ in:•~ tllc :k~
t:1i•W11 1;.:.· ,1q,h;1nit·
=..-=. ......-'-''-'-'-'-'-.
Pr~n,:b, who i:; lhc i:on- Alnleist 9C~; :t~J..Gi:!tl l! "'bu~ll, u,ln;;: .1 pl~lic t:..:iz~f tht:rh'l!rb~:1. ,,,.::, i) -~...~,•,lo
-'-'---'------·----'
•:•:k;m;, ut 1Jf h1,1IIu:..1tt·r
n:iC ~c·, 'o!C lnfra!;lr,1..::-
.n1!:fat£l,;:I\\. 1111ru- ,:11,-
t1.1ri:, tl!J'-4'~ \\II t)Dit1il1;11t)
iw:lll 11 for l',V, 11-.irin1: :o·.~.:::.:u,1ththe JuU,orL- \\.\\'Ith ·olu:.1t.:-er;:;,c::en::i- Prosp!!n.Ly f'l:in fo-r tbe ·1::~ · ~-~rnn~n"t pl:ms (C~l'S) n:"11\\1\\'a.I~;, ::;:.11- thl! rcm.:.iinir.;::-lEt1.311d:~
l1.". r c,:-nt, 1h111f.:,IJ !II :, 1Mul•J1-1l\\Y.l•~•1h:1tk,1t1. li~1.(-C•llll-llJllil it-31() I.JujhJ t\\.,..\\I r<J1!1 'r'•'.lYc., ::i:A11il:l- 10 h111wh Cl,1rnw1rnj• i1:,1i,)ci :lw.l Hn.:i,•::1\\! lt•iJt'l'i l,y Ol-.\\.l y~.u
1tr t:-hdder C:\\;'a:;ei-r.:~nt i;>rio.ril\\'". Ne i:rt· ~J:J.cr I!:, t:'lilct..nndd:-Jn~-: l:•!-:1~·;- tio:1;.s:J5C:.arri,:,ri:T
ty-lt:d Tot.cl :;.init.itlfln (\\.':t\\Sl I) Jwn-cnt!Sf ?,:i-n
•llni:,:
.:in rdlt "nll:11~•·l11IJ~ftr• ~n!,!:-:,:a.,t; :,11~!.",d/'· ~h-: iour," ~In: 11r,l1!
tlrip~c-r~• de::uJJ,:r.:tc?In Jppr..:nh!d.
• :,;l~t..:2.Ll."11'.~.I;.h, i! c:n1~
"t1t111il•i:1twhl :•I r,.-.rli:1• D',V·:.·1.1tl:!"..,:~u1i:·l.•:i:mv.·ti :,.:i,:d, c-:~p•n•~-$tlw.n•
merit en •,:1t,.l:.)~:t.101;
nltif1~ ~-.111li!,•:11 .tiuthn1·- v..-11l1l~u• ii, W:'0i.'11t,1~! e:-
fn line v,•itl: T•~rti:,- iti<.:.: to m · ·:: inionu:il lfom•!nts to de;uily di.1-
rmmt~,.,l1Jf11:1,rw;,::,,•1.i1 "''' l!ern,.-11~1.(lr\\!:i•1_:,.f-.! • r.~ H t-.l!'>!t, 11.1,·h :1~ u.1,1;,
·,r.t1H!; !;rnitat1:m tn b~ 1:i1llr1.ifn.:i.:.
Th,; pt~·•~r::rnm~It l:c111~
r,l:i:~... , ~tt I hi:i :\\!rtl r l' .J~ ii
rulJ ·I•>tll in ck:h1 diht•r•
.,! ~crl:il:.prnr,:•.utlr.n.· CoU~.b¢1·nU~n
\\ nt h) .. tl'>,
··on:J,."1,.-.!:;:.;o;~r.lj• 121.'°;.• •· 1Nt h:i•;t!;, rcl.iti,:.n:-;h:p
,wi:-: rci;i:;t,::-,:.,Jt--fa-
1)! r.·.~;ld{(ul.1;1,l)1(11rn1:)I with 1.h~1:1ii'.i!lri-:~ M.;1,:- mi:Uianr. ,::::oV.'it.l/i,r,'a;;,
~: :tk:mc:.1lsho\\'!;, tnlkl r1r:.1!:1~rr.;1:ulltr:-,1:bill~:I ,.11;1.u,;t.1:.i11nl.u•krhr1n:le~
:Jl b:rn:'!' .-'.h:-io~ y1:~ .i.rt: :no:.th· '.','!! 'Nnr...•:Nlth thl! "ll!bf111:~nti,:nforn:.:J!(!t•
1,1~in~ rl·,t' l,u-,h. 1;.~~111,;-,
rhl) t It: l:r1g f;f [h ;• I 1-I,' I·
b~1.·:::hc.~;,iLl.
P~nch ::il;J t:,!!i' w;1:,t
'.,:1;:-.1i1l 1,mlr:ip.!Etits.C.1r
1,/lh:Hi !"1111ih l't!t' lll!lll:,:.
1r1.1.it:,1~fflC:t:~.wi': ... lj
.1·N;,rtkd :;pii:.-:.'N~\\~\\Jr!;
tlc1nt11~!\\:.mi th,: dhc..vl-
\\'Old·,~1111 (!llllllllUJ1ilk:,;
lh..:.tr~1;idr. in !Jh:m. hi
the :,;cct.rnd B:u;1:-11bl.!c
[10]
Question 5
"The urban poor who eke out a livelihood in Africa's slums arguably pay the highest transaction cost
to be in the city: a clear manifestation of the systematic failure of states and the market."
Discuss the primary drivers of urban policy failure that are relevant to Namibia.
[10]
Question 6
Throughout Africa there are repetitive urban forms dating back to precolonial times. Identify and
discuss the most significant characteristics.
[10]
Supplementary Memorandum
Page 3 of 4
July 2022
|
|
6 Page 6 |
▲back to top |
Comparative African Cities
CAC610S
3
'"t} t :,.,'~-..:.. . .. .1:!-Ct;dy,:-_,:~::ud-
-.::J:1! m~i·-t·o~t'.T·...:;
,t, . .,.,'-
.:i..:dl..:...~s.':.'i;it:\\i:: 1.:!I~.
.
'
,,
-~i{.j,•p;._1:,: l:.\\--·.,i•~1ih·p,~1-·,1t!l:
rl1,11.•m11111:.1tl-.1.•·1.•i.l:h:·
ti•)/! ~•ll.1ttjfl1,. 1;_: ;,f I:··••!~\\··
11:;::i lll'••l:1111:l:·111:1::;I
r.:. ri 1.rh,i,·.,r,:.1~.
:=_;_:__:•_;~-t~:,/?J--~t~,:;'.'_f'~,_,/.•;_'·:·'::;·{r:':f:a_·i::jf=\\~~;f;;~ :.:;,j!,::.{l;;=.,; '1\\i:~ilc.~
,.:ipw·:o:-.i,v-1Q:;-
:1.::'.;~U.
~_:_r.._: ,_-.'..-.·.~:~-:_:.~.--·_.;_;f l._1_·~--:r...__~_·._;=_.-._.·.~_~-,:_: ___
.-
·:· ·-.
.
1,
011 nr:,•:rag1.',
:t.::.~ i ·;}'.~~~:=;~~ i~-;::~,~•':::
.., _'-:::J~•:!:h:1·;)c:1t:: d11 :11:t
!::,•.. · c1,i:,,1, :11'.f'1t,.:•1r:I·
,·:in:!;,c v:,:,;\\;,:;}1r1i~lf"•',1.::
..,,.,.L/. ,/t-:)_
nn!J•1:2·~o-fn:,:.,~-
frfc-;1fs ill fi;ji.Jt•,
ma/ scltlt·m.cnt~-
/.un-:oe tojkt- ul'
--·--~ d·•.:- !~ .U• i:-111...,./ :,:; -·
lwmt:.
,:•..·!y!:•'•lid•.;;:c-1d.(l Ii", ll•)i
5,:~p:1,111i,ifr.,r.::11,
:,.·..-.,::•. ,..,.h ::. \\!/indlu:d,.
Co11:;ul1IIIAa,.;.·,1::.:.t:1:
l\\ td:-1b. O:j1'.1::,·:,:n:~.,,.
Dl•~-~1~~..,!.'(.,-i 11.'r:.r1•
\\~~.: ,1:•:1 ,. h1Iii:.!. (J;11: V -::
!.h.:?(D'H)
.•;nl t_1•:l·.:-.k:.:,.1.:i1,1::r•! the
!.:. ;:,••,; ••r,;li-:111~. 1Jr i;,-
i-:-:-uJ: ::::UIC':TI•!:ltt..t :.r.:
"l:J-:.::::\\;ur:: •,•;:.:sm.iJ:::
.: ~---·:~.:~_\\./
;: ."1••<1•. ,, !:'r I i-1 •l~;i;;i t'
__
F·:-:-r.,:iiw. i,.;b, tiu1..::,1;:-1Alt'li!.'.l:J9:tJ";; :r;; •~~:,.-:t•~-~:.aHh,u:;l,1" .1 ;:,t:..:.\\i,:t~z ,,- th:: rh-.!rO::-:!,~...).- :_,·,:.i,,,t'-l
:··~ ~:=·;t.:.
.-...."..!_..__
• -~----
;•.:l:.1!J ...h-,;,,1 f,:::- .:,n-
i;;J: i:: n {i: r ::)i,1/, 11'.!:-in!! :~-.~c:.: 11;:::1 :l:.zl•••U1c; ~- with 1.·.:.Ju:ll"~~r~:,: t;1:i1:;i- C"'r,.:•~r.,-:r.Lsf•~;,n f,:-.r :.'.'II!
h.":.:· ~:,.,r.rdl,1itkol,
!11 ;,
-:r;.}_'!':Jr:1:f:•J!':ttl;~!!1:-~•:-_nr.
~:_;,~~~1:~•;:·:·.~~':~i~~:~;~1\\;~~::·;~=:;:~r~,.i-\\i:·'~.:~:i~'i;:~::\\~;~:~-:··:,i'~~~:'rL-'-)-.·t~;he .:.;H,;•.I ,: ;.,nfl:w.du~ p:·•r·
1•.:, In l""li\\?.t•~:1,i-:,U,:,a •
lf•p1:::lt.-1f.
D'.1.: ~--•1_1d,~: i:i:-:•:r·."'lm•-.t
1i!•!•:-:•Hl:-,1J11"\\1i,;--.1-_1l111:1;11:.,~, r,m1 :,•·-•r'·,-t>rtir:1•
t:,ik~ ,-,111i-:!:1ni!·.:r:;",::.·.·1·.i,;:-;:< :J~,:,,1 ;,n,,n:~·
li~;:11~d. (';~;II)'•~';-
c:m·
1rr"' .
;;;:.::.-...::t1 ·,:,•-.:•.L1:.':.;J";' o!ti11:. >·m! li 0 .•:1l ;,11:h:11·- v.·ht'',I!,., i, 1 111:"ut:11:.~i:c-:-
;:1 Li,,,. •::it.I: P-.~rti:,· iti,..:.-;l::o m:J:~ i.:::.·,,n,;::! l lt!:11•!:"1~to$ .:fl!;uil:;cii!;-
fl:.~ .=-:i~·~·rrin:..~prbr:n..s
111 l·,111wh ,::,;,inni~111i-
tv b:1 T•:Hal !:..lnit,1:-io.1
t1.1ro:.:<t:-.,s ·,1 ,-l1111i11:,:,·
(CLT~iJ ;1:-1111.\\'~I,.:..:'.:>:.fl· thi.: rcta.J! ,11r:.;:.~.31111,~k:----:
jl:l\\i,:,ri :ini.1 l[!·~il 1>l•~ 1.v:.:..1·1~.:i_.-.,,,1 :n·11
('t'.--.-\\$:11J',)\\";t.;"¢il:!SS !t:•Ul
tln:-1:
\\:;;~:•:;~:_);:11_r'; ~!:,1~~; :1~1~:' :111:ut":,,ll,l•·::J,;\\:(,:=,. ,,.: ,,,1 ll~r1,·, 1•~-''l'-..'.a·•~..;~-
·.r.i :, ::; ~J;1:i:;1;:i,i;:. te1b~· ,:;1lin.--:!1\\!I.!.
l,i;1:· 0 ,l:tl lh•• ;y;;:rt•.,.-. ;!
r:.,IJ:--,·:,!11l in,:i::h1 ,1it:',·r-
·.•:..:: 'cn:i::• r.irn::•."iitl<: n.· Cotl~b,o,-.'.)!.:ion
'(:n -:-.,·1!-::.~~.::;d1:,:·::1,--;_• 1,V:-h:1':t!,4rd.1::,:in::lq1
!..'•',\\' !:: :. rc;i,;!•!:-:-:J!'b·
, :· :-:::1,i.·H:; i,, h,~:1:·m-•I wj~ii l!1l.'l:":i1:i?l1:,:-.,::Jf',!·
l!l!'.1ian:.-::-:uo:irl. !,, r,~····
:.;::::f.::rn1.::1t...,J1a:\\1·t,:otl=t r::·.1l:1.:.ri:11:Htl1'-·::l:J•.,1 .. :I (1:1 ,;u;;.1~;1.1!:-l:: lu!'inr. :h!
:.'l !-::in:~~'.l!:.-111,~;,:1:•:-:•:re: :rw:;::,•\\·,·t,.:,,.-11•.,•-::It-h: tt;~ -.o!k.pi..::-.nt, i:if,:>rn:.:Jtl!t·
.1:-<n~ rl,< '"'"h. •:•::a_;.:<r
·11.;,-:11:l:,1:51:-1tl·:1 1h,1:.
1.)-:-,::, • ::ho!-~;,i:...
:-:1-:.iml ::1:...iri;-;1!:tie-:t:;:-.u
,, 11k1"; :111•ir-l':-ti!llll,:l\\:.:-
i[:.d.it:,: ,·.t!°tri:.~, '.\\"1' ;_,·,·
1!1.•nti!:--: ~.111.l!h•! d!:-t.,•1·;
j n111.i:1:;,.,,I (:1:mml1:ii1/..:1-,
ih.:.t r.:.•;;iJ,:b lh.:r,1. j.-,I
r:.-:11,h::1i;! 1:1:.:y·,t:1:u J·:.-;1rckd:.µ:::.~.'.V=w•::ir!; lb:. :;•!•~•mci lhr;r:i1Gt'\\! ·
[10]
Question 5
"The urban poor who eke out a livelihood in Africa's slums arguably pay the highest transaction cost
to be in the city: a clear manifestation of the systematic failure of states and the market."
Discuss the primary drivers of urban policy failure that are relevant to Namibia.
[10]
Question 6
Throughout Africa there are repetitive urban forms dating back to precolonial times. Identify and
discuss the most significant characteristics.
[10]
Supplementary Memorandum
Page 3 of 4
July 2022
|
|
7 Page 7 |
▲back to top |
Comparative African Cities
CAC610S
:)."!c',rn•~ni~:H".".:i:~
3
. - ··-·--·----·
Thi:5 i:;.infor.ned IJ,J
.1 :!i:..!d~'..::.:..-1~.::ud-
·~d'.u }l1Dj,_.!·.to~~.,-.,..,:;
.:;:-d1-c,:;~'1ith~ttJcf.:.
~.;;-u-i0fOo,~ih.,.airon-
:;v~[(;rii1;'lJ ,>:\\1:lHo,
()pUt-t'll ~tvJ Q:-;;-
:1...-/:atf.
-""..!2!1~bl:,··t::1;:btiJi.:rc:nt
;_l'il :·,1'Jir.::-,..;li;"iiit:\\1ri11:1I
~~~llh:mc;1t:; dn ~,c-t
h:1•.':· tt,~i~i,I! :l1•: fli..:?d·
,.:;-•m~r,\\l'l:',)t!:sJ-1!1[i In•,1;::
··:t?.i:; 1:::.r.hWuh.'1.i it'.' .·
,:·..-!r r-:,nd-..:-:ctli.n11.1},:•r
:,,',',-11;; •l.!ath lh \\ 1...i11,1h1W~i-
::;:tr:b-16. +:}:jiv:r1:,:n;!_~·,.
~;~1:i,~1:,1~l;1lii-,0Q.~_n;,~,:,
.•.-;-uul ~h:":k:,ti,1..1.·}1:.!trhee
:.:. ?-1::,,; i-,,;;li\\111!'- uf i:1-
l,:ir:nJ.:! :;~::tk·m-!1tt. ;.re:
·r:i:: f.-~ut~ •u.is en,1Jt:
t:,;•,,,.,n'1::,: !sl1•vl~:11:i\\·
Ji':~nd"I. wh,.:, i.:.lhe ~0:1-
.;•.11.:d:i :d','.;,u
i;:i:i::n ii:,r-:J'N,1brb~ :c,·;n:--:v~.-,thtire-JLitJ1n;!. v,itlt 1;0.:.Ju:lt~er:::;t;.~~cn~i• f'rQ::p=.r:1-.f:•,,~;:infor 1:"I~
r,u:.:,,..n. ~. h.:r <1-,;.r•.ti-lh1llk1l1 M :, 1~-vs , .. 1,:1<'11,~I;"rni::,1.i~u 1. ~i::.•!1;-:.•m;::,1m?lid1~_,l111i1l::I;..-r1
:-IJ.llif:)•
:o:tt-}:-=-:lr=e~--:i:;l'a!r.;~1.:.~nr ;:.rio.rit-·y·1.1J:cii(!· r.:.llt:rtt:- t:-iilct..iind-.:!-...Jnt:!t•.~;-,1;•t.i-!.l::1H :.ls"';, pri,:iri:7.
.:in:.rd.t! 111:h:w,,·lJ1I',J!;lt· -!nl,!~,..!,!:,t ;,11J~,\\dt.." ~h-! i1)ur;':-;h,: 111;,\\•!•l.
ucir-J:.:,r:, d,:~u:,:m<:'y in
l'-1"1-:1·.il•::11-i:•hl:11 :"'.:tdia-
ml!r,t c n ·1,,:~.b::::,da~~.
Jf•fH:nkd.
"Th~ .,;l:;.:1.!i:i1.::,~:hc c:111·
[l',1,•)·:,_1rl;~.u-:.::•.-:•:1·."ti'l::,m:11•!:d.·. ~;ii1''"~•:1 tfw-~•t i
1lltif,~ ..-.ad k,·at :iu.i:h:u-- v.·h1'.I! ,v i;l .u:·1)~rr:.1:~c:. I
i:1 l.~m: ,..,.itf-. P'lr!i:.i• iti.-.~.tso m,J.:.~ b1£nrn .;.:il tli:=m-:n~t to ..J~;nii:t di~-
~111:,1t':,:1!1J,1::f1l\\~'i,°?J•.e!ldi •,i•Ij J~nl•.'! \\/.~.1 ir,! :1-,.:.,:>f,..:-:-.1~.t!!- ,1.11'!1 lt~:ul\\l i; "F..
·.•r:rn~::~J11irn~1.:li::t.CJb" t::i1lfo~ fn:t.!.
Th•: 1a,;,~r:1rnm,:I~t'.!:n,;
(•i:i:;~1!,1i lh>! l.\\'.r-tltlt.J?. !I
rnU:.•·i•>Ujl;i,.:i::;!11.,Jifi',•r·
·.:;~: 'cd:a::. orn;;:,:,rtlr,,n.""' Cof!.:l!'o-Ot·.::i.tk•n
~·nt:t,);. :.1-.,
..On :-..,·!!:-:.~:~j.1:1iJ·Z'i"c· • 1.Vt::h.1';l! u r!!l.1.::,:,;i::lq, L~•,Vi:: rr:!:"=i::::!,::!r"Jb-
,·f ;..::1loit'.1,;; h, iw:\\1n11:il 1.-.-i;ll~t11~1:'!.i1:.iil'.1:~ ui:--J.· m~i;i;m ~-:GOu,:ii:lihf• ..;1~,
:;:-·:d-:::r.c~1hLo,,;--:ii tn1lr:t t :a.-:d:1.:r,~1J;luw1:-11:1:h::.:I l.'.H:I.uisf.!-'iu1bl:! ulf,or. :h.:·
:1l b-iit'.~. :'.!::in~ s,1:1?.-.;ir~· :no:::~\\"•.-,•,c,,.:nr':,wld1 U;..i Yd::a111r.~11i:t1.forn:.::.!.'ll!.t·
.,, i1\\'.;:r: it' 1,u~h. •.:.!~H_;.:i '....:.1~ml imii:-i~;;Etit•$.f},1r 1.h~1ne11~;!,n\\ d th>! di·:e.,.l,-
~11:Jf!·h;l:o~ 1:..-rl!.-· d·n1r. 1·,!lit.:1":'u..;-•}ir~1'.ne1111.111=,:-\\·n11.l:1!,!1.1(:11l:111utii :di~;.
b-~·.:·1~,he .~;iii.!.
1f.·.djt/ di"1e:o:~, •.,11:;.,·,: th..::t r~~idi! i~ lh~Tfl. b
r-~nd-1 ::rd 1:,!:'f \\·,·;1:n .a:u;m.!.,::=d:;p;i:'~,-.V!1,,~,;ar(; ti::: :1..:,;,;,nd ffara:1,bc\\!
i.'l:.t .~. '>!':rnn:..-:-1p1la: n!;
1(1 l;,1u::dL C1.,1rm1tJ11j-
?;.· b:l ·1'.:,t.il :;l.11 it.1~in.1
;:1-.~-L~I:.l·..~·.:;i,11·11!tlu•.:-,n!ll
tliC1::,1.11111i:',ill'.:1.i\\.:t"rik·
ti .,.1. 1.::,fl.1tn11,.!;::ilbw--:-·
!1:1:,i 111:1,.-I:,, 11:!::111 :11"::I
1:,:ri·url1;J;:;.rc.1: .
On nr:N'i!.~t.~,
nnly 12¾ ofr,:s-
.•.·-.
frfc·;1fsiu i1;_,for,
i 1nafscJtlc.m.t~Jlts
bmst o toild ,11
.1 fµ),'llt' •
.~--::J:j S,:~ht111i-: f'i"(r-,.:h,
Ccn:;ul1111~i11hl-::i 1.!r:
I
D!:!\\·e1oprn,.J<,1It".'rsrl1-
!:ILL";.'(D'h')
i
_JT.:)!:2:111b1tiuo1:.1!:J::1d~•>
t;i·,~•if:'1'.!~•!i,,11i.l.1w iH·{ ~11-
'.'r;:iLrl:itOt~ i111,:, ~JI•::k·
·:'.'11.~;.111•,.1._(l-:nutl.li• •.i.:1~.:1·
r1:1C .,c·;;·,.!r 11!fr:i:..trJ..::·
u.,r-~-:.i1.t., ~,·, ,di1qi 11;;:,:
(t.::Ll'~:) a:11I\\\\-~t,:;, .":>:..11-thr.!rcr.w1r1ii:;..:::..::1:1; ,id:~
i1n;i,:m am.l H1·~i1,.'.:-1•:t1,:1~1~t,_r,,,,:-,J p•.,t
('t',::"\\SII)JW."l.T~.1:..:.ss- :,:, m
•!111:-1;
[10]
Question 5
"The urban poor who eke out a livelihood in Africa's slums arguably pay the highest transaction cost
to be in the city: a clear manifestation of the systematic failure of states and the market."
Discuss the primary drivers of urban policy failure that are relevant to Namibia.
[10]
Question 6
Throughout Africa there are repetitive urban forms dating back to precolonial times. Identify and
discuss the most significant characteristics.
[10]
Supplementary Memorandum
Page 3 of 4
July 2022