QUESTIONS
Rule 10.2 of the official rules of hockey states that "protective headgear must be worn by a
player with goalkeeping privileges when defending a penalty corner or penalty stroke." Rule
11.1 states that "(the) umpires control the match, apply the Rules and are the
judges of fair play."
During a local club match Tally was playing as a player with goalkeeping privileges. Umpire
Bonga noticed that she was not wearing a face mask when preparing to defend a penalty
corner. He stopped the game and asked her why she was not wearing a mask, to which she
replied that the mask made her feel hot and sweaty. Umpire Bonga then said "okay" and
allowed the match to continue. Towards the end of the match Tally was once again defending a
penalty corner without wearing a mask when the ball hit her in the face. She sustained a severe
injury.
Tally's friend Teven, a NUSTdropout who is incomprehensible even when he is sober, advises
her that she can claim her medical costs resulting from the injury from the umpire and the
hockey union.
Answerthe following questionsbasedon the above facts:
5.1 List the elements of a delict.
(5)
5.2 Advise Tally on her chances of being successful in her claim against Umpire Bonga. (10)
[15]
QUESTIONG
The players of the Magic Stars Football Club (MSFC)are not satisfied with their remuneration.
The players made a demand for the creation of a pension fund and an adjustment to their
remuneration so that contributions can be made to such a fund in addition to what they
receive. The club's management failed to respond. The players decided to revert to industrial
action.
Answerthe following questionsbasedon the above facts:
6.1 Which industrial action can the players revert to? Motivate your answer.
(2)
6.2 Discuss the procedures which need to be followed before the players can embark on a
lawful industrial action.
(10)
6.3 After the dispute has been resolved some of the players are very upset to find that their
wages for the duration of the industrial action has been deducted from their monthly
remuneration. May MSFCdo this? Motivate your answer.
(3)
[15]
TOTAL MARKS 100
4